News Article

Court of Appeal Dismisses Tesco’s Challenge to Lidl Store Approval

Court of Appeal Dismisses Tesco’s Challenge to Lidl Store Approval

15th May 2025

On 9 May 2025, the Court of Appeal dismissed Tesco’s legal challenge against a previous High Court decision regarding Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council’s decision to approve Lidl’s proposed store at Wellington Road North, Heaton Norris, Stockport.

This is a nationally significant judgement with respect to the retail sequential test.

Tesco argued the Council misapplied the retail sequential test in national planning policy by overlooking two potentially preferable sites. At the time of the decision, both sites had confirmed interest from competing retailers but neither site was open and trading.

The Court agreed with the Council’s view that those sites were not genuinely available, as they were already committed to other occupiers.

The judgment of the Court of Appeal, given by Sir Keith Lindblom, Senior President of Tribunals, is significant in reaffirming the discretion planning authorities have when interpreting availability and exercising planning judgment—particularly in retail cases where alternative sites may not be available in practice.

Rapleys was pleased to act for Lidl Great Britain Limited in securing planning consent and supporting their position throughout the judicial review process.

Jonathan Harper, Partner in Rapleys Planning Team, said:

 “This judgement provides important clarification as to how an assessment of availability for the purposes of the retail sequential test should be undertaken.

There had previously been some ambiguity around this point, following the Aldergate Properties Ltd and Mansfield District Council High Court Decision which was issued in July 2016.

It is extremely positive that the retail case put forward by Rapleys, which was accepted by Stockport Council in their decision, has been found sound by both the High Court and Court of Appeal.”

Please get in touch with our Planning Team if you’d like to understand the wider implications of this judgment or to discuss your potential development sites.

Get in touch

Key contacts

Gain national and local expertise through our multidisciplinary teams of experts.

Partner & Head of Rapleys Living – Residential

Angus Irvine

Partner – Building Consultancy

Dave Ensor

Partner – Charities Not for Profit

Adam Harvey

Partner – Charities Not for Profit

Graham Smith

Associate Partner – Commercial

James Clark

Partner – Building Consultancy

James Porter

Associate Partner – Commercial

Mark Frostick

Partner – Building Consultancy

Alex Marsh

Partner & Head of Residential – Residential

Nick Fell

Partner – Building Consultancy

Simon Harbour

Surveying Technician – Commercial

Stacey Jolly

Associate Partner – Planning

Wakako Hirose

Associate Partner – Management Consultancy

Robert Frost

Partner & Head of Neighbourly Matters – Building Consultancy

Dan Tapscott

Partner – Building Consultancy

Natasha Bray

Partner – Building Consultancy

Jason Mound

Partner – Head of Housing Consultancy

Martin Gladwin

Partner – Building Consultancy

Richard Crow

Senior Surveyor – Commercial

Thomas Fagan

Associate Partner – Planning

Abraham Laker

Head of Bristol Building Surveying

Adam Reed

Associate Partner – Building Consultancy

Chris Barnett

Senior Surveyor – Building Consultancy

Dan Heath

Associate – Building Consultancy

Felix Carter

Surveyor – Building Consultancy

Jack Hussey

Associate – Cost Consultancy & Project Management

Reiss Thompson

Associate Partner – Building Consultancy

Richard Howard

Associate Partner – Building Consultancy

Ryan Kerr

Associate Partner – Planning

Adam Rabone

Associate Partner – Planning

Ben Larcombe

Graduate Building Surveyor – Building Consultancy

Elliot Pascoe

Associate Partner – Commercial

Nik Moore

Associate Partner – Commercial

Campbell Moffat

Learning & Development Manager

Karen Wilcox

Surveyor – Neighbourly Matters

Curtis Murphy

Programme Manager & Resident Liaison Manager

Liz Locke

Consultant – Investment

Ken Morgan

Partner – Technical Director

Paul Dunne

Senior Surveyor – Cost Consultancy & Project Management

Harriet Beesley

Partner – Head of Public Sector Development Consultancy

Jonathan Bernstein

Head of Facilities Management

Peter Hayes

Team Assistant – Town Planning

Alison Ludlow

Service Charge Accountant

Andrew Emery

Senior Commercial Property Manager

Anna Hitchcock

Executive Assistant to the Senior Partner

Caroline Emile

Property Accounts Administrator

Christina Dalton

Executive Assistant to the Managing Partner

Clare Stewart

Facilities & QHSE Compliance Manager

Helen Earwaker

Head of Business Development & Marketing

Katy Blake

Executive Assistant to the Residential division

Lisa Stratford

Associate Partner – Health and Safety Compliance Manager

Lyndsey Foster

Executive Assistant to the Commercial division

Marika Frost

Consultant – Property Management

Neil Spurrier

Assistant Client Accountant

Ollie Wills

Head of Property Accounts

Tracey Lee

Consultant – Property Management

Lynn McNeil

Consultant – Property Management

Ruhul Khan

Consultant – Lease Advisory

Duncan Preston

Head of Project Management & Cost Management

Phillip Ankers

Partner – Joint Head of Central London Office Agency

Julian Leech

Joint Head of Central London Office Agency

Jonathan Stern

Client Accounts Administrator

Rina Hance

Associate – Neighbourly Matters

Nathan Edwards

Partner – Project Management & Cost Management

Chris Bees

Partner – Project & Cost Management

Dan Jones

Partner – Head of Retail

Dan Kent

Partner, Head of Retail Investment

Scott Mitchell